Now that you’ve gained a clear understanding of what cognitive behavioral therapy for
insomnia is and how CBT-I Coach can supplement treatment let’s discuss some
limitations. As we mentioned, CBT-I Coach is overall a great app. However, like
anything else, it does have a few drawbacks.
Designed to Supplement In-Person
Therapy
CBT-I Coach is meant to be a companion app to supplement in-person therapy. Hence,
it’s not designed to replace in-person therapy or stand-alone. In fact, the VA has
said it is a “mobile companion for in-person therapy for promoting better sleep.”
With this, the VA is very cautious when marketing the CBT-I Coach app. They’ve added
a disclaimer during the onboarding process that states, “CBT-I Coach does not
replace professional treatment.” Furthermore, they include a qualifier
on their site that details, “CBT-I Coach is intended to augment face-to-face
care with a healthcare professional. It can be used on its own, but it is not
intended to replace therapy for those who need it.”
Stellar
Sleep is a better choice for those looking for a stand-alone, digital
intervention for insomnia. In other words, the Stellar Sleep app is designed to be
used as an alternative to in-person sleep therapy.
CBT-I Coach Does Not Offer
Comprehensive Content
Since CBT-I Coach is meant to supplement professional treatment, their content is not
that comprehensive. In fact, the main emphasis of their content is to highlight
information that’s not typically stressed during in-person treatment sessions.
Nonetheless, it’s information that the user may find interesting as supplement
reading material (e.g., the science behind relaxation techniques and insomnia).
Crucially, this means that CBT-I has significant gaps in the covered content. One
thing that stands out as missing is all information related to cognitive
restructuring, as this is something that an in-person therapist usually covers in
great detail. In fact, at least one or two out of five sessions is based on this
concept, so they do not need to repeat the information in the app.
On the other hand, using the Stellar Sleep app, you’ll find that it covers
the same set of
information (and we aim for more) that is taught during in-person sleep
therapy. Our app includes information related to the following:
- The science behind insomnia
- Stimulus control
- Cognitive restructuring
- Sleep restriction
- Sleep hygiene
- Relaxation techniques
CBT-I Coach is Unstructured and Text
Only
Another thing that some users may find unsuitable is that all of the content included
on the CBT-I Coach app is presented as paragraphs of text. Quite simply, where user
experience is concerned, the curriculum included on the app is best described as a
textbook in the form of a mobile app.
In contrast, Stellar Sleep presents content in a way that’s engaging, interactive,
and personalized. We guide users through a structured, daily program. We offer audio
modules, text modules, information panels, quizzes, questionnaires, exercises, etc.,
to make our program as engaging as possible. Moreover, our program is personalized
based on the user’s inputs (e.g., sleep questionnaires).