Sleep Apnea vs Insomnia: How to Tell the Difference
Two different conditions, two different treatments, and a large overlap that catches people out.
The short answer
- Obstructive sleep apnea is a breathing disorder in which the upper airway repeatedly narrows or closes during sleep. Insomnia is difficulty falling or staying asleep despite adequate opportunity.
- The classic OSA picture is excessive daytime sleepiness with loud snoring, gasping, choking or witnessed pauses in breathing, often alongside morning headaches and night-time urination.
- The classic insomnia picture is lying awake, at the start or in the middle of the night, and feeling tired rather than sleepy during the day.
- No questionnaire can diagnose or rule out OSA. In-laboratory polysomnography is the gold standard, with home sleep testing an alternative in some cases.
- The two occur together often enough to have a name — comorbid insomnia and sleep apnea — and treating one while ignoring the other tends to leave the person still sleeping badly.
OSA = obstructive sleep apnea
For education only, and not a substitute for advice from your own doctor or prescriber.
Do your answers fit the pattern for insomnia?
Four yes/no questions, about thirty seconds. Your result shows straight away, and no email is needed.
Both conditions wreck your nights and cost you your days, and plenty of people do not know which one they have. Here is how they differ.
Two different problems
Obstructive sleep apnea is mechanical. During sleep the upper airway repeatedly narrows or closes, breathing is interrupted, and you surface briefly — usually without waking enough to remember it. The sleep is there in quantity; the quality is not.
Insomnia is difficulty falling asleep, staying asleep or waking too early, despite having adequate opportunity to sleep.2 With insomnia you generally remember lying there awake.
What each one looks like
OSA typically presents as "excessive daytime sleepiness, loud snoring, gasping, choking, or witnessed episodes of breathing cessation during sleep," along with morning headaches, nocturnal reflux, nocturia — and, notably, insomnia.1
Insomnia typically means taking more than 30 minutes to fall asleep, or being awake more than 30 minutes in the night, on three or more nights a week for three months or more, with a daytime consequence.2
The most useful clue is the difference between sleepy and tired. Someone with untreated OSA may fall asleep in front of the television, in a waiting room, at a red light. Someone with insomnia is exhausted but cannot drop off.
The clue that is not reliable
Snoring.
It is strongly associated with OSA, but its absence does not rule anything out. Some people with OSA do not snore loudly. Plenty sleep alone and have no idea what they sound like. And women with OSA more commonly report sleep-onset and sleep-maintenance insomnia symptoms than the classic snoring picture — part of why OSA is diagnosed in far fewer women (9–17%) than men (25–30%) in the US.1
So "I don't snore, so it isn't apnea" does not hold.
Risk factors worth knowing
Obesity, advanced age, male sex, sleeping on your back, alcohol, smoking, and the use of sedatives and hypnotics all raise the risk. So do anatomical factors such as enlarged tonsils or adenoids, and conditions including diabetes, hypothyroidism, stroke, congestive heart failure and atrial fibrillation.1
Diagnosis
Insomnia is diagnosed clinically, from your history and your sleep pattern.
OSA is not. It requires measurement: in-laboratory polysomnography is the gold standard, with home sleep testing an appropriate alternative in some cases.1 No questionnaire can diagnose or exclude it — a screener can only indicate likelihood.
The AASM's sleep center directory lists accredited facilities, searchable by distance and state.4
When both are present
They are separate conditions, and having one does not mean you have the other — but they are diagnosed together often enough to have a name in the literature: comorbid insomnia and sleep apnea.
The sequence is easy to picture. Fragmented breathing produces broken nights; broken nights invite the behaviors and the anticipatory arousal of insomnia; now a mechanical problem and a learned one are running at once. Treating one and ignoring the other tends to leave the person still sleeping badly, which is why a careful assessment looks at both.
What to do
If anything on the OSA list applies to you — pauses in breathing, waking up gasping, loud snoring, morning headaches, or waking unrefreshed after adequate sleep — take it to a doctor and ask about a sleep study. Untreated OSA is associated with serious cardiovascular conditions, and it is not something to work around with sleep advice from the internet, this page included.
If you are lying awake with adequate opportunity to sleep and there are no breathing red flags, that points to insomnia — and CBT-I is the first-line treatment.3
Common questions
How do I know if it is sleep apnea or insomnia?
Can a questionnaire diagnose sleep apnea?
Can you have both?
If I don't snore, can I rule out sleep apnea?
Should I do CBT-I even if I might have sleep apnea?
Do sleeping pills help if I have sleep apnea?
References
- Obstructive Sleep Apnea. StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf.
- Insomnia chapter, International Classification of Sleep Disorders, Third Edition, Text Revision (ICSD-3-TR). American Academy of Sleep Medicine; 2023.
- Edinger JD, et al. Behavioral and psychological treatments for chronic insomnia disorder in adults: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine clinical practice guideline. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine. 2021;17(2):255-262. doi:10.5664/jcsm.8986
- Sleep Center Directory. AASM Sleep Education, American Academy of Sleep Medicine.
Next in this path
Why You Keep Waking Up at Night
Everyone wakes in the night. The question is what happens in the minutes afterward.
Insomnia Symptoms & DiagnosisWhat Causes Insomnia in Women
Women report insomnia symptoms more often than men. Does insomnia more commonly affect women, or is this merely a difference in reporting?
Insomnia Symptoms & DiagnosisWhat Is Insomnia? Symptoms, Causes and Treatment
Insomnia is not a number of hours. It is a specific pattern with specific criteria, and knowing them is the difference between a bad month and a treatable condition.